April 30, 2018

On May 7 Minnetrista’s city council is considering an ordinance to ban short-term rentals (defined as less than 30 days). There are two sides on this issue, residents who want the ban because of unruly renters and residents that don’t because they rent out their homes. I’ve been getting emails for several weeks from both sides, have talked with many of them and honestly sympathize with them all. I believe residents that manage their properties responsibly and are considerate of their neighbors in making sure renters are properly vetted should be allowed to continue renting their properties. I also believe that irresponsible property owners that use irresponsible vacation rental companies and continually cause problems for neighbors should be fined and after a warning should not be allowed to do it anymore.

What is the magnitude of the problem in Minnetrista and what should the remedy be? The remedy, obviously, should be relative to the magnitude of the problem but the city doesn’t know how big the problem is because we haven’t been tracking it. I asked the city to tell me how many citations have been issued over the last three years relative to short term rental properties and the answer was, basically, they don’t know. I asked how many complaints have been called in to the city over the last three years due to short-term rentals and the answer was they really couldn’t say since it’s difficult to know whether or not calls to a specific property were related to the short-term rental usage (i.e., they don’t keep track of that information). Are these complaints coming from one or two properties? Five? Twenty? We don’t know because we haven’t been keeping track.

I know people want this issue dealt with quickly but a hasty decision to impose a ban is likely to harm responsible property owners that are good neighbors and rely on rental income to make ends meet. My guess is most wealthy people don’t rent their homes. Those not so well off, however, may depend on that income for their very survival. I think we owe it to them to at least take the time to measure the scale of this problem so we can arrive at a measured, appropriate response to it.

I believe it would be appropriate to spend the next year tracking Minnetrista short-term rental properties by identifying them on the top vacation rental sites, and tracking complaints about noise, drugs, assaults, even parking violations associated with these properties. If we find it’s a wide-spread problem on a large number of properties we can remedy it accordingly with either a ban or requiring a license and enforcing new regulations. If we find a small handful of properties are the problem I think we need to issue citations and fines for the behavior, not only to perpetrators/renters but property owners as well.

The council is not there simply to react to large volumes of emotional emails. It is there to carefully weigh and determine the facts, possible courses of action, and then consider the impact of those actions on the entire community. We need more facts before we can do that. Until we can measure the problem we can’t provide an effective solution to it. It may take a year to gather the needed information but whatever solution we arrive at will be a responsible, well thought out one rather than an emotional one. I hope Minnetrista residents will support finding the best solution rather than a quick one.

April 21, 2018

The full closure and detour for Westedge Blvd./CR 44 is currently expected to begin next Wednesday, April 25. Once the closure begins, REGIONAL TRAFFIC WILL BE …

See More

METROCOUNCIL.ORG
Metropolitan Council Environmental Services (MCES), operator of the metro-area wastewater collection and treatment…

April 15, 2018

Minnetrista pulls plows from roads because of snow. Really. Dear Minnetrista: There are good reasons to pull plows off the roads (allowing for rush hour traffic, accident inaccessibility, etc.) but heavy snowfall is NOT one of them. I was out in my Ford Expedition Saturday afternoon driving through knee to waist high drifts easily in 4-wheel drive. The reason we have city plows is so EVERYONE can be safe and have access to emergency services if needed. What’s next, pulling our police officers off their routes because there are too many criminals?
http://www.cityofminnetrista.com/home-news-2/plow-alert

Image may contain: snow, tree, sky, outdoor and nature

April 3, 2018

John Tschumperlin was appointed last night on a three to one vote to fill the council seat vacated by Patricia Thoele. Mine was the only dissenting vote solely for the reason that the current council doesn’t have any representation from the southern developing neighborhoods of the city and we had two very qualified candidates from that area interviewing last night. This southern area is where growth is occurring and where we’ve designated new commercial zoning (along Hwy 7). It will likely be the site of a new water tower and treatment plant as well. Mr. Tschumperlin has been on the Planning Commission and will bring that valuable experience to the council and I welcome him and look forward to serving with him. There will be two Minnetrista council seats up for election in November, this one and the seat currently held by Pam Mortenson.

IF YOU’RE NOT IN AGREEMENT WITH YOUR PROPERTY VALUATION: Attend the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization/Open Book meeting at Minnetrista city hall on Wednesday, April 25. Hours are 4pm to 7pm. Call for an appointment: 952-472-0619

March 30, 2018

I’m pleased to see we have four candidates vying to fill Minnetrista’s open council seat. I’m looking forward to meeting them Monday night and having an opportunity to interview them. I take this 9 month appointment to the council very seriously because this person will be the incumbent, if they choose to run, in the November election and will have an incumbent’s advantage. Here are the candidate names (in alphabetical order): Ryan Boogren, Scot Pekarek, Cathleen Reffkin, and John Tschumperlin.

Some thoughts going into Monday’s meeting after reading the candidate letters and resumes. I’ll reserve judgement until after the interviews but I see that three of the candidates are relatively new to Minnetrista and I don’t see that as a negative at all. A fresh perspective can be a good thing. I value the experience and longevity of one of our planning commissioners that has applied as well. The three fresh faces live in the southern subdivisions of Minnetrista (yes, I looked up their zip codes). That will be the location of future commercial development and continued growth so I’m happy to see the interest from candidates in that area. Our current council is heavily weighted from rural and lakeshore areas.

Whomever is chosen by the council to fill this seat should, in my opinion, be the individual that would most likely have been elected had there been a special election. That’s not an easy thing to predict but I am interested in hearing what’s important to Minnetrista residents and I’m sure other councilmembers are as well. Email us your thoughts: lwhalen@ci.minnetrista.mn.us; sbruce@ci.minnetrista.mn.us; mmolitor@ci.minnetrista.mn.us; pmortenson@ci.minnetrista.mn.us. Or, better yet, come listen to the interviews at our worksession Monday, April 2 at 5:30pm or sign up under “Persons to be heard” at the council meeting at 7pm to express your views.

Can I vote for just one council candidate?

“What if I only want to vote for one?” That’s a great question! There are two seats on the ballot for Minnetrista city council and three candidates running. The ballot says “Vote for Up to Two” but what if you only want to vote for one? Will it disqualify your ballot 2018ballot? I asked the MN Secretary of State’s office and they confirmed choosing only one candidate WILL NOT INVALIDATE YOUR BALLOT. It says vote for “UP” to two so it’s fine to choose fewer or even skip voting for an office altogether. The best thing to do, however, is find out who the candidates are and what they stand for, even all those judges you’ve probably never heard of. #ElroyBalgaardForCityCouncil

March 20, 2018

Councilmember Patricia Thoele resigned her Minnetrista council seat last night effective today, March 20, 2018. Citing a move to Excelsior as the reason, her seat will likely be filled by council appointment since the seat is up for election in November. Special elections are only required if more than two years remain in the term. Candidates may contact Minnetrista’s city clerk if they’re interested in filling the seat until a successor is elected in the next election.

February 21, 2018

City of Minnetrista refutes economic principles of marketplace competition:

IT’S CLEAR FROM OUR MEETING LAST NIGHT THAT CITY COUNCIL HAS NO INTEREST IN SEEKING COMPETITIVE RATES WHEN IT COMES TO PROFESSIONAL SERVICES CONTRACTS for engineering services. One council member actually stated she didn’t think it was necessary to do anything that the League of MN Cities didn’t require the city to do. I wonder if she knows the League of MN Cities has no jurisdiction whatsoever over Minnesota cities and never has. The state doesn’t require cities to competitively bid professional services contracts but many cities choose to because they know that without competition prices go up. Minnetrista is sending a message, loud and clear, to constituents that its allegiance is not to taxpayers but to special vendor relationships.

Arguments against seeking competitive bids last night ranged from (and I’m paraphrasing since the video isn’t accessible yet) “We don’t want to lose the knowledge and history we’ve had with our current firm” to “Request for Proposals (RFPs) are expensive and don’t facilitate competition.” My response was we don’t necessarily need to lose the knowledge and history with our present firm. If they want to respond to an RFP with competitive rates we can choose to keep them. RFPs are not that expensive, especially when you consider the likelihood of getting more competitive rates as a result.

Minnetrista hasn’t competitively bid their professional engineering services contract for over 13 years. Is it any wonder our current engineering contract allows them to charge the city $90/hr for general clerical work?

Evidently in 2016 the city council then was concerned with this same issue and asked staff to research other engineering firms and their rates. What was shown to us last night was a 2016 matrix of 3 firms and their ranges of rates for work performed by different positions within each firm. Some of these rate ranges varied by close to 90% between the top and bottom part of a given range. It was evident, to me at least, that given the wide range of prices at which a particular position could be billed out, that it would be impossible to accurately compare these firms by looking at ranges of rates in this manner. This was simply a futile exercise designed to put off the matter without issuing an RFP.

I had hoped that the special presentation last night titled “Professional Services DISCUSSION” would actually be a discussion about the merits of competition in the marketplace, how seeking competitive rates could benefit our community and lower our rising infrastructure costs. What we got was a one-way presentation by the City Administrator giving reasons we shouldn’t issue an RFP. When I asked a question during his presentation I was told by the Mayor to write down all my questions and wait until the end to ask them. Clearly we have different ideas of what a “discussion” is.

Also at last night’s meeting:

COUNCIL MADE A DECISION AT THEIR WORK SESSION TO PROHIBIT SHORT TERM RENTALS in residential areas, defining “short term” as less than 30 days. The number of residents concerned about this issue has been growing in the community. Staff will seek input from the Planning Commission before holding a public hearing on the issue and will then submit an ordinance for council’s approval at a future meeting.

February 17, 2018

IF YOU CARE HOW YOUR MINNETRISTA TAX DOLLARS ARE SPENT YOU WILL WANT TO ATTEND TUESDAY NIGHT’S MEETING (2/20 at 7pm, council chambers) and let council know that it is time to make sure Minnetrista is getting competitive rates on engineering services. We spend a huge portion of our annual budget on roads and infrastructure projects and it has been 13 years since we’ve officially evaluated competitive rates in this market. My sense is staff and council may need encouragement from constituents to make this happen.

I had asked for a work session to discuss rebidding Minnetrista’s professional services agreement for engineering services at a previous meeting and we agreed to schedule it for a work session. Work sessions are designed to allow for free discussions. I just saw there is now a “Special Presentation” titled “Professional Services Discussion” on our council agenda. Special presentations at regular council meetings are usually one-way (hence the word “presentation”) but this item says it is a discussion so I’m hoping that is what it actually is and not just a staff member giving all the reasons why we should not rebid this contract.

I’ve been contacted by several residents that have given examples of what they consider over-priced projects from our present firm and I have encouraged them to attend this meeting to voice their concerns and also to send their documented concerns to other council members. I have expressed my own concerns regarding rates in the past, specifically charging $75/hr for clerical work. Interestingly subsequent to that meeting our contracted engineering firm changed the title of that category to “office technician” and raised the rate to over $80/hr.

I am not making allegations of unethical behavior by anyone. I am advocating that since there are concerns from residents that those concerns be taken seriously. We have an obligation to assure residents the rates we’re paying for engineering services are competitive. We simply cannot assure that when it has been 13 years since they’ve been evaluated.

I have learned that engineering companies often provide ranges of rates in response to proposals from cities and, depending on who performs the work, the rate could be toward the upper end or the lower, depending on the skill level of the individual. I have advocated, should the city decide to rebid the engineering contract, that Minnetrista require specific rates for specific tasks from all the firms that respond to the bid. Skill levels can be categorized and specific rates identified for each. Unless we do that it will be impossible to compare them. Ranges of rates are unacceptable in my opinion and don’t promote competition.

If you can’t attend let your council members know where you stand on this. Minnetrista City Council email addresses: lwhalen@ci.minnetrista.mn.us; sbruce@ci.minnetrista.mn.us; mmolitor@ci.minnetrista.mn.us; pmortenson@ci.minnetrista.mn.us; pthoele@ci.minnetrista.mn.us